A manuscript by Christopher I. Rider


Yeah, Yeah, But… and Therefore

How to Frame, Design, and Defend a Contribution in the Social Sciences

This manuscript teaches framing and theory alongside design and identification, treating the argument that frames a contribution and the evidence that supports it as a single craft. Written for early-career social scientists working without a deep bench of empirical mentors, it carries one worked example from an interesting question to a defended contribution, and pairs with a free companion site of code and tools.

Work in Progress

Companion tools, live now 1 · PlanDifferences-in-Inferencesdevelop your idea into a contributionFor any method: Contribution Architecture 2 · ExecuteNumerical Narrativesmove your audience’s beliefs accordingly

Free to use: each tool runs in your browser with no account, and its code is open on GitHub.

How the manuscript works

From a split craft to a defended contribution

Each chapter leaves you holding one artifact, and each artifact is the input to the next.

The integrationTwo strands, one craft
Framing and theory question mechanisms contribution data design estimate Design and identification The argument that frames a contribution and the table that estimates it are the same object. This manuscript integrates them. Framing and theory question · mechanisms · contribution data · design · estimate Design and identification The argument and the table are the same object.
The procedureNine chapters, one artifact each
Part I
Possible
Chapters 1–2
Ch. 1
A question that denies a prior
Ch. 2 ◆
Three rival mechanisms, a signature each
to the design brief
Part II
Plausible
Chapters 3–4
Ch. 3 ◆
The design brief and threats list
Ch. 4 ◆
The three-model table: replicate, diverge, reconcile
Companion tool: Numerical Narratives · primer
to the chosen design
Part III
Probable
Chapters 5–7
Ch. 5
The chosen design, with the ideal it approximates
Ch. 6
The credible comparison, defended threat by threat
Ch. 7 ◆
The contrastive figure, with the simulated truth marked
to the abstract
Part IV
Therefore
Chapters 8–9
Ch. 8 ◆
The six-sentence abstract and its introduction
Ch. 9
A paper that integrates argument and evidence
The belief shift is the contribution.
Stands alone on a project already under way gate“Before you proceed”: the audit that closes each chapter
The coreRuns through every chapter
As rhetoric
Yeah, yeah…
but…
and therefore
As evidence
Replicate
the prior result
Diverge
with the novel result
Reconcile
with the mechanism, by a boundary or a bias

On your own project, plan with Differences-in-Inferences (or Contribution Architecture, for any method) to develop your idea into a contribution, then execute with Numerical Narratives (see the primer) to move your audience’s beliefs accordingly.

One worked example, the effect of mentorship on promotion, runs the length of the manuscript, on simulated data whose truth you write in yourself (b_true = 0.08) and then try to recover, so that every estimate can be read against the answer it ought to reach.